Nurse dismissed over weekend working wins appeal

A nurse has won her case of unfair dismissal after she refused to change her working patterns to include weekends.

Gemma Dobson was a community nurse with North Cumbria Integrated Care NHS.

She had worked fixed days because she had three children, including two with disabilities.

However, she was dismissed after the trust introduced weekend working. She said she was unable to work Saturdays and Sundays because of her childcare responsibilities.

Dobson brought claims to the Employment Tribunal, saying that she had been unfairly dismissed and been subjected to indirect sex discrimination.

The tribunal ruled against her saying that her dismissal was not unfair because, under the Equality Act, “being a female with caring responsibilities” was not a protected characteristic.

Dobson took the case to the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT), which ruled that the tribunal had failed to take into account the “childcare
disparity” faced by women in the workplace.

Crucially, the EAT ruled that the tribunal was wrong to say the new policy did not create a group disadvantage because it failed to recognise the childcare burden that fell disproportionately on women.

The judge, Mr Justice Choudhury said: “The tribunal erred in not taking judicial notice of the fact that women, because of their childcare responsibilities, were less likely to be able to accommodate certain working patterns than men.”

He added that weekend working was a policy “that was inherently more likely to produce a detrimental effect, which disproportionately affected women”.

The case was remitted back to the Employment Tribunal so that it can be decided in light of the EAT’s ruling.

Please contact us for more information about the issues raised in this article or any aspect of employment law.